+1 (855) 353-1100 info@keyauctioneers.com

Online Only Real Estate Auction of Luxury Lake Retreat in Sister Bay Wisconsin

Online Only Auction

Bidding Ends (Soft Close)
Thursday, December 1
1:00 PM (CT)
Preview By Appointment Only

Bidder Registration:  All auction participants must be registered and approved to bid by Key Auctioneers.  All bidders will be subject to fulfilling the following requirements prior to being approved to bid. Bidders must execute the Auction Terms and return them to Seth Seaton, sseaton@keyauctioneers.com, along with a copy of a Government-issued Photo ID for the individual registering. 

Due Diligence: In addition to the documents posted below, the following documents will be available upon request; Home Inspection, Preliminary Title Commitment and Purchase Agreement which the high bidder will be required to execute upon conclusion of the auction.  Requests for these documents can be sent to Seth Seaton at ssseaton@keyauctioneers.com or by calling our corporate office at (855)353-1100.

Auction Details

This Luxury Lake Michigan Retreat is truly a one-of-a-kind property.  The home was custom-built to provide an experience for the owners and their guests, as they clearly had a passion for the natural beauty of Northern Wisconsin and the shores of Lake Michigan.  This is obvious not only from the design and aesthetic, but also the location of the home which is nestled in the private and gated Marshall’s Point Nature Preserve.  The property boasts over 21 beautifully wooded acres and 800’ of Lake Michigan shoreline which is visible from both the custom marble patio and all three stories of the home.  From the time you enter the home you feel warm and cozy as you are greeted by a double-sided fireplace in the entry foyer which leads to the great room or either wing of the home.  The layout and lighting continues the sense of warmth one feels as you move through the home.  The interior finishings include antique heart pine floors, Bertch cabinets, Juparana Gold counters, exposed steel ship hull trusses and natural stone fireplaces, to name a few.  Tom Birmingham, Owner of Great Northern Construction, said it is, “one of the finest homes that my company has ever built.”  While there are too many to list, some of the features of the home include a 360-degree observation tower, outdoor kitchen, library, three-season’s room, butler’s pantry, wine cellar, walk-in cedar closet and outdoor playset.  The new owner of this property will be able to find year-round enjoyment by just getting away from the fast pace of day-to-day life or by taking advantage of the activities within Marshall’s Point such as hiking, cross country skiing, bird watching or playing tennis and basketball.

To read the press article from the Milwaukee Business Journal, click here. 


Address 9531 Marshalls Point Bay Road, Sister Bay, WI
Lot Size 21.2 Acres
Year Built 2001
# Rooms 17
# Bedrooms 4
# Baths 4 Full
Square Footage 8,735
Appliances included Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Freezer, Hood Fan, Indoor Grill, Microwave, Oven, Built-In Double Oven Range, Refrigerator, Trash Compactor, Washer
Fireplace 2
Basement Partial
Garage 3-Car, Detached
Property Features Marble Patio, (2) Walk-out Decks from the upstairs bedrooms, Covered drive-thru entry, Gated Community, Outdoor Kitchen, Wine Cellar, Walk-in Cedar Closet, Butler’s Pantry, Four Season’s Room, His & Hers offices, Walk-in Master Closet with Custom Built-in Cabinetry, Cummins Deisel Back-up Generator, Heated Workshop, Outdoor Playground, Priceless view of Lake Michigan from your own private retreat!
Marshall Point Association Amenities  Tennis Court, Hiking Trails, Cross Country Skiing 
Assessed Value $4,594,200
Real Estate Taxes $39,819.37 (2015)

For more information, contact
Seth Seaton
(317) 353-1100 (Office)
(317) 450-6469 (Cell)

Key Terms
10% buyers premium will be collected
Licenses: AC30900124; Seth D. Seaton (AU10900115)